Small Business Marketing Agency Reviews Spot the Fakes ftimg

Small Business Marketing Agency Reviews: Spot the Fakes

Table of Contents

TL;DR:

Small business marketing agency reviews are worth reading for the details more than the star rating. Real reviews name the service and the people who did the work, and they arrive gradually over years. Fake ones are vague and tend to show up in bursts from accounts with no history. Confirm what you read by calling a past customer.

Key takeaways

  • A review that names a service and a person at the agency is more believable than one that only says the agency was great.
  • Review dates should match how long the agency has been open and how long its projects take.
  • Buying or writing fake reviews is against federal rules, and an agency that does it for itself may suggest it for you.
  • Reviews narrow the list, and a phone call with a past customer makes the decision.

Where should you look for small business marketing agency reviews?

Start with Google, then check at least one place the agency doesn’t control. Google reviews are tied to an account and a date, which gives you something to examine. Testimonials on an agency’s own website were picked by the agency, so they only show the best ones. Facebook recommendations and the Better Business Bureau are worth a few minutes too.

If an agency says it’s local, its reviewers should be local. For a marketing agency in Richmond, VA, you should recognize some of the businesses leaving reviews, or be able to find them in Henrico or Chesterfield. The Google reviews on our own site run through a Trustindex widget that confirms each one came from Google. We’d still suggest clicking through and reading them on Google itself.

What does a real marketing agency review look like?

A real review reads like someone describing a project they paid for. It names the service and a person at the agency, and it usually says how long the work took or what changed afterward.

Real reviews are also uneven. Some are two sentences long, some ramble, a few have typos, and now and then one mentions a problem that got fixed.

Check the dates. An agency that has been working for years collects reviews slowly, a few each quarter, with gaps. Ask how long projects take and compare that with what the reviews say. Our custom websites take about 90 to 120 days from design through development, so a review praising a finished site a few weeks after the reviewer says they signed on deserves a second look.

How can you tell if a marketing agency review is fake?

The clearest signs of a fake review are vague praise and a reviewer profile with nothing else on it. Timing is the next thing to check.

What to check

Likely real

Likely fake

Detail

Names the service, a person, or a result

General praise that could describe any business

Timing

Spread over months and years

Many reviews within a few days

Reviewer profile

Other reviews of nearby businesses

One review total, or reviews scattered across the country

Wording

Uneven, sounds like one person

Several reviews with the same phrases

Agency’s reply

Mentions the actual project

Same pasted thank-you on every review

Click the reviewer’s name on Google and you can see everything else they’ve reviewed. A profile that rated businesses in four different states in the same week was probably paid to do it.

AI-written reviews are harder to catch by wording because the grammar is clean, so lean on the profile and the timing. No single sign proves anything. Two or more on the same review, or the same sign across many reviews, is enough to discount them.

Are fake reviews illegal?

Yes, fake reviews are illegal in the United States. Businesses now risk civil penalties under a Federal Trade Commission rule if they buy or sell fake reviews, and that includes reviews generated by AI. October 21, 2024 is the date it took effect. Company insiders who write a review have to disclose their connection to the business. Hiding honest negative reviews is covered as well. Google’s own policies also prohibit fake reviews.

This matters when you’re hiring because an agency that fakes its own reviews will probably suggest the same for you, and then the penalty is your problem. Reviews affect how a business shows up in local search, so any agency selling SEO services in Richmond will bring them up. Listen to how. Asking your real customers for reviews is fine. Anything involving purchased or scripted reviews is a reason to leave.

What should you make of an agency’s negative reviews?

A few negative reviews are normal, and how the agency replied tells you more than the complaint does.

Look for the same complaint showing up more than once. One customer upset about a missed deadline could be a bad month. Four customers over two years describing slow replies after the contract was signed is how that agency works.

Then read the replies. A calm reply that addresses the specifics is a good sign. A reply that argues with the customer or shares private details about the account shows you how a disagreement with you would go. We’d trust a rating a little under perfect, with complaints that were answered, over a spotless one.

 

How do you verify an agency beyond its reviews?

Ask for two past customers you can call, and look at the agency’s work yourself. Pick customers close to your size and industry. Ask what they paid for, whether deadlines were met, who they dealt with day to day, and whether they’d hire the agency again.

Then check the work. Open the websites the agency built on your phone. Search for one of its SEO customers by service and city and see whether it shows up. Scroll through the social media accounts it manages and look at whether real people are commenting.

Find out who would do your work, too. We keep ours in-house, and you can see the people on our team page. Some agencies sell the project and hand it to contractors the reviews never mention.

FAQ

How many reviews should a marketing agency have?

There’s no number that proves anything. A few dozen detailed reviews spread over several years say more than hundreds posted in one season. Compare the count with how long the agency says it has been in business.

Should I trust testimonials on an agency’s own website?

Trust them less than reviews on Google. The agency chose which ones to show, and some sites don’t link back to the original. If a testimonial names a business, look that business up and see whether the work is still live.

Can an agency delete bad Google reviews?

No, an agency can’t delete them. A business can flag a review for breaking Google’s policies, and Google decides whether it comes down. That makes the negative reviews you see, and the replies under them, a fair record.

Is it okay for an agency to ask its customers for reviews?

Yes, asking is normal and allowed. What the FTC bans is paying for a review on the condition that it’s positive or negative. A wave of five-star reviews right after a giveaway or discount offer is worth questioning.

What if an agency is new and only has a few reviews?

A short review history is fine if the agency is honest about it. Lean harder on reference calls and live work. Ask to start with a smaller project before signing a long contract.

If you’re comparing agencies in Richmond, read our reviews the same way, then get in touch and ask us for customers you can call.