When to Hire a Marketing Agency 7 Signs Its Time ftimg

When to Hire a Marketing Agency: 7 Signs It’s Time

Table of Contents

TL;DR:

It’s time to hire a marketing agency when marketing has become a job you can’t do well in the hours you have. The clearest signs are leads that have gone flat, ad spend you can’t tie to sales, a website that doesn’t bring in calls, and competitors showing up above you in local search.

You’re running the business and the marketing at the same time, and the marketing keeps getting pushed to Sunday night. If you’ve been asking “how do I know when to hire a marketing agency,” the answer usually shows up in your calendar and your numbers before you admit it. Below are seven signs to check your own business against, plus a few cases where hiring would be a mistake.

Key takeaways

  • Flat leads for two quarters or more usually mean your current approach has run out, and doing more of it won’t change the result.
  • If you can’t say which marketing dollar produced which customer, tracking is the first thing to fix.
  • An agency makes sense once you have an offer that sells and a monthly budget you can hold for at least six months.
  • A business still figuring out what it sells should wait, because an agency can’t solve that for you.

How do I know when to hire a marketing agency?

You know it’s time when the marketing work your business needs is bigger than the time and skill you can give it, and the gap is showing up in your numbers. Most owners feel this before they can name it. These seven signs make it easier to name.

  1. Marketing only happens when you have a spare hour. Posts go up in bursts and then stop for a month, and the ad account is still running on settings somebody chose two years ago.
  2. Leads have been flat for two quarters or more. One slow month is normal. Six months of the same number means the approach has hit its ceiling.
  3. You’re paying for ads and can’t tie the spend to sales. If the only report you have is clicks and impressions, you don’t know whether the ads work. This is the most common reason owners ask us about Google Ads management.
  4. Your website gets visits and very few calls or form fills. The traffic is there and the site is losing it, which usually points to slow pages, a confusing layout, or no clear next step. That’s a web design problem more than a traffic problem.
  5. Competitors show up above you in Google Maps and local search. People looking for a local service tend to choose from the first few results they see. If a newer company in Henrico or Chesterfield outranks you for the service you’ve offered for fifteen years, they’re doing local SEO and you aren’t.
  6. You’ve tried freelancers or a part-time hire and the work comes out in pieces. One person runs the ads and another updates the website, and neither is responsible for whether the phone rings.
  7. You have a growth goal and no plan with numbers behind it. Wanting 30% more revenue next year is a goal. Knowing how many leads that takes, and what each lead can cost, is a plan.

One sign on its own is worth watching. Two or more at once is usually enough to start making calls.

Which signs mean I should hire a marketing agency right now?

Signs three and four are the urgent ones, because in both cases you’re already paying for something that isn’t working. An ad budget with no tracking goes out every month whether or not it produces a customer. A website that doesn’t convert makes every other channel more expensive, since the visitors you paid for or earned land on a page that loses them.

The other five signs cost you growth you haven’t had yet. These two cost you money you’ve already spent, and they tend to get worse the longer they run. If either one describes your business, fix it before you add anything new, whether you hire an agency or do it yourself.

When is it too early to hire a marketing agency?

It’s too early if you haven’t sold your service to enough customers to know who buys it and why. An agency can bring more people to an offer. It can’t tell you what the offer should be, and paying one to guess is an expensive way to find out.

It’s also too early if the monthly fee would have to pay for itself in 30 days for you to make payroll. Paid ads can move fast, but SEO and content take several months to show up in your numbers, and a business that can’t wait will cancel right before the work starts paying off.

Until then, there’s free work that matters. Fill out your Google Business Profile completely and ask every happy customer for a review. We’ve written more about that in our Richmond local SEO tips.

Is a marketing agency better than hiring an in-house marketer?

An agency is usually the better fit for a business that needs several skills part-time, and an in-house marketer is better once you need one skill full-time. Marketing a local business takes someone who can write, someone who can build pages, someone who can manage ads and someone who can read the analytics. One hire rarely does all four well.

Freelancers work well for a single defined project, like a logo or a batch of product photos. The trouble starts when you need four of them, because then you’re the project manager, and you’re back to sign one.

In-house makes sense when your product is complicated enough that the marketer needs to sit with your team every day, or when you publish so much that an outside team would cost more than a salary. Some businesses keep one in-house coordinator and hand the specialist work to an agency, which is a reasonable setup once you’re big enough to afford both.

What should a marketing agency do in the first 90 days?

In the first 90 days, an agency should get your tracking working and audit what you already have before it spends much of your money on anything new. You should be able to see where each call and form fill came from by the end of the first month. Without that, nobody can tell you what’s working, including the agency.

After that, the work should focus on one or two channels, chosen by where your customers already look. For a home service company in Henrico, that’s usually Google Maps and search ads. For a law firm downtown, it may be organic search and a much better website.

Expect a report every month that tells you how many leads came in and what each one cost. Be careful with any agency that guarantees a number one ranking or asks for a long contract with no way out. Ask to see past work for businesses like yours before you sign anything.

FAQ

How much does it cost to hire a marketing agency?

Cost depends mostly on how many channels the agency manages and how much ad budget is involved. Ask for a quote that separates the agency’s fee from the ad spend so you can compare offers fairly.

How long does it take to see results from a marketing agency?

Paid ads can produce leads within the first few weeks, while SEO usually takes several months. Plan on at least six months before you judge the whole relationship. Judge the first month on whether tracking and reporting are in place.

Do I have to sign a long-term contract?

No, though many agencies ask for a minimum term because slower channels need time to work. Whatever the term, make sure you own your website, your ad accounts and your data if you leave.

Does my marketing agency need to be local?

No, but a local agency helps if your customers are local. A Richmond team already knows that Short Pump and Southside are different markets, and it can come to your shop for photos and video instead of using stock images.

What should I have ready before I contact an agency?

Have logins for your website, Google Business Profile, ad accounts and analytics, plus a rough monthly budget. It also helps to know what a new customer is worth to you over a year. With those two numbers, an agency can tell you quickly whether your goal is realistic.

If two or more of these signs sound like your business, set up a call with FreshMove Media.