Marketing Agency vs. Employee for a Small Business ftimg

Marketing Agency vs. Employee for a Small Business

Table of Contents

TL;DR:

For most small businesses, a marketing agency makes more sense than a marketing employee until there is enough daily marketing work to fill a full-time job. An agency gives you several specialists for a monthly fee that is often lower than one salary with benefits. An employee makes sense once you need someone inside the business every day.

Your marketing has outgrown the hour you give it on Sunday night, and now you have to decide who takes it over. For most owners that comes down to hiring a marketing agency vs. an employee. Both can work. Which one fits depends on how much marketing work you have each week and how many different skills it takes to do it.

Key takeaways

  • A marketing employee costs more than the salary, because payroll taxes, benefits, software and your own management time all sit on top of it.
  • An agency covers more skills than one person can, which matters when you need a website, search rankings, paid ads and social media at the same time.
  • An employee is the better choice when the work is daily and has to happen on site.
  • Many businesses that grow past the early stage end up with one employee who handles daily content and an agency that handles the technical work.

Is it better to hire an in-house marketer or a marketing agency for a small business?

For most small businesses, an agency is the better first step and an employee is the better second step. The reason is the range of work. Marketing a local business takes a website, search rankings, paid ads and social media, and each of those is its own trade. One person is rarely good at all four.

What usually happens with a single employee is that they are strong at one thing, often social media or writing, and the rest gets done slowly or gets sent out to freelancers anyway. You end up paying a salary and outside invoices.

An agency has its own downsides. The people doing the work aren’t in your building, they have to learn your business before they can speak for it, and they are working for other businesses besides yours. If you want someone who can walk onto a job site with a camera on ten minutes’ notice, an agency won’t be that.

What does hiring a marketing agency vs. an employee cost?

A marketing employee costs you a salary plus everything attached to it, and an agency costs a flat monthly fee. On top of the salary you pay payroll taxes, benefits, software subscriptions and equipment. You also pay with your own time, because someone has to set priorities and review the work, and in a small business that someone is you.

The agency fee covers the people and the tools. Ad spend is separate either way, so leave it out when you compare the two numbers. You can see what’s included in our marketing services.

 

Marketing employee

Marketing agency

Monthly cost

Salary, payroll taxes, benefits, software

One flat fee, tools included

Skills covered

One or two, depending on the person

A specialist for each channel

Time to start

Weeks to recruit, then training

Usually within a few weeks of signing

If they leave

Work stops until you rehire

The agency assigns someone else

Best for

Daily, on-site work

Technical work across several channels

What can a marketing agency do that one employee can’t?

An agency can put a different specialist on each part of your marketing in the same month. A designer builds the site while someone else sets up the ad account, and neither one is learning on your dime. With one employee, those jobs happen one after another, and some of them happen for the first time.

That matters most on the technical side. Web design, local SEO and Google Ads management all punish beginner mistakes, and the mistakes are expensive. A badly built ad campaign spends real money on the wrong searches before anyone notices.

There’s also the question of what happens when someone quits. When a marketing employee leaves, the logins and the half-finished projects tend to leave with them, and you’re back to recruiting. An agency absorbs that turnover without your marketing going quiet.

When does a marketing employee make more sense than an agency?

A marketing employee makes more sense when the work is daily and has to happen inside the business. A restaurant that posts a new special every day needs a person on site with a phone. So does a contractor who wants video from every job, or a retailer running events most weekends.

An employee also fits when you already know which channel brings in customers and you need more hands on it. If email drives most of your sales and you want it sent four times a week, that is a job for one person who knows your products cold.

Before you post the job, write down what this person would do in a normal week, hour by hour. If the list fills forty hours and most of it is one kind of work, hire. If it runs out by Wednesday, or it reads like four different jobs, you have your answer.

Can a small business use both a marketing employee and an agency?

Yes, and for a business that has grown past the early stage it is often the best setup. The employee handles daily content and customer replies, and acts as the agency’s contact. The agency handles the website, search and ads.

The split only works if it’s written down. Decide who owns each channel and who approves what, so a task doesn’t sit for two weeks while each side assumes the other has it.

FAQ

How long does it take a marketing agency to get results?

Paid ads can bring calls within the first few weeks, and SEO usually takes several months. Ask any agency you interview what they expect to show you at 30 days and at six months.

Do marketing agencies lock you into long contracts?

Some do and some don’t. Read the cancellation terms before you sign, and be wary of a long commitment with no way out.

Who owns the website and ad accounts if I leave an agency?

You should, and the contract should say so. Before you sign, confirm that the domain, the website, the ad accounts and the analytics are all set up in your business’s name.

Is a freelancer a good middle option?

A freelancer works well when you need one skill, like ad management or writing. It gets harder when you need several, because then you are managing a handful of freelancers and coordinating them yourself.

Does it matter if the agency is local?

It matters less for the technical work and more for knowing your market. An agency in Richmond already knows the neighborhoods and the competition here, and can sit down with you in person when something needs talking through.

If you’re weighing this decision for a business in Richmond or anywhere in Virginia, get in touch with FreshMove Media.