Manage Your Own Social Media or Hire Someone?
Table of Contents
TL;DR:
Manage your own social media if you can give it a few steady hours every week and your sales don’t depend on it. Hire someone when posts keep slipping for weeks at a time, or when an hour of your time earns the business more than a social media manager would cost for that hour.
The business page went up two years ago, and the most recent post is a holiday hours notice from last winter. If that sounds familiar, you’re probably asking whether you should manage your own social media or hire someone, and most of the advice out there comes from people selling one answer. We sell social media management, so weigh that. Plenty of owners still shouldn’t be paying anyone yet.
Key takeaways
- Doing it yourself works when you have steady time each week and most of your customers find you some other way.
- Hiring makes sense once missed posts are costing you customers or your own hours are worth more than the fee.
- A freelancer, an employee, and an agency are different purchases, and the cheapest one often needs the most supervision.
- Whoever you hire, the accounts and the content should stay in your name.
Should I manage my own social media or hire someone?
Manage it yourself if you have the time and social media is a small source of customers for you. Hire someone if it’s a main source, or could be, and you keep failing to post.
Those two things, your time and what the accounts are for, decide most cases. A restaurant in Scott’s Addition or a boutique in Carytown depends on Instagram in a way a commercial roofer in Henrico doesn’t. For the roofer, a tidy page with recent job photos is enough, and the owner or an office manager can keep that up. For the restaurant, a quiet month on social media shows up in the dining room, and that’s the point where paying for social media management stops being optional spending.
How much time does managing your own social media actually take?
More than most owners expect, because posting is the smallest part of the work. Before a post goes up, someone has to decide what the week’s posts are about, take the photos or video, write the captions, and schedule them. After it goes up, someone has to answer comments and messages and check which posts led to calls or visits.
Whether those hours happen every week matters more than how many there are. An account that posts daily in March and then goes quiet until June looks worse to a new customer than one that posts once a week all year.
If you run a crew or work the counter yourself, the hours come out of your evenings. Be realistic about that before you decide.
What does a social media manager do that I can’t do myself?
A good social media manager works from a plan made a month ahead and reports on what the posts did for the business. Owners doing it themselves almost never get to either one.
Most also handle the visuals, so your posts match your website and your signage. That’s the part where trained graphic design shows, because templates from a free app start to look like everyone else’s templates.
There’s one thing a social media manager can’t do, and that’s know your business the way you do. Expect to answer questions and send phone photos from the job site or the shop floor, especially in the first two months. Owners who hand over the logins and disappear get generic posts.
What does it cost to hire someone compared to doing it yourself?
Doing it yourself costs hours, and hiring costs a monthly fee, with a freelancer usually at the low end and a full-time employee at the high end.
Option | What you pay | Your time each week | Where it tends to go wrong | Best fit |
Do it yourself | Your own hours, plus a scheduling tool if you want one | The most | Posting stops when the business gets busy | New businesses and owners who enjoy it |
Freelancer | A monthly fee | Moderate, since you direct the work | One person, so sick days and other customers affect you | Simple accounts with one or two platforms |
In-house employee | Salary and benefits | Low once trained | Hard to find one person strong at writing, design, video, and ads | Businesses posting daily across several platforms |
Agency | A monthly retainer | Low, mostly approvals and sending photos | Generic posts if the agency never learns your business | Businesses that want design, video, and reporting from one team |
A simple way to compare is to put a dollar figure on an hour of your own time and multiply it by the hours social media takes you each month. If that number is higher than the quotes you’re getting, hiring is the cheaper choice.
Ad spend is separate in every row. And posts alone rarely reach someone who needs a plumber this afternoon, because that person is searching, not scrolling. If most of your customers find you that way, the money may do more in Google Ads management than in a bigger posting schedule.
When does doing it yourself make more sense?
Doing it yourself makes more sense when the business is new and cash is tight, when you enjoy it, when most customers come from referrals or search, or when your own face and voice are what people follow. In that last case nobody else can make the content anyway. A social media manager can edit and schedule, but you still have to be on camera.
There’s a middle option that works well for a lot of owners. You shoot short phone videos during the week and a social media manager handles everything after that. You keep the part only you can do and hand off the part that keeps getting skipped.
And if social media is one piece of a bigger gap, with an old website and no reviews coming in, look at the full list of digital marketing services before spending the whole budget on posts.
What should I ask before hiring a social media manager?
Ask who owns the accounts and the content, who will actually do the work, what they’ll need from you each month, and how they’ll report results. The answers tell you more than a portfolio does.
Ownership comes first. The pages should be created under your business, with the social media manager added as a user, so you can remove access in a minute if things end badly. Ask whether they shoot original photos and video or work from stock images, because customers spot stock images quickly. Ask what the report includes, and push for calls, messages, and website visits over follower counts.
Contract length is worth a question too. A few months is a fair trial for a Richmond social media agency or a freelancer, since the first month is mostly learning your business.
FAQ
How often should a local business post on social media?
Post as often as you can keep up all year, which for most local businesses is a few times a week. A steady schedule you can hold beats a heavy one you drop after a month.
Which social media platforms should a local business be on?
Be on the one or two platforms your customers already use, and skip the rest. For most local businesses selling to the public that means Facebook and Instagram, while businesses selling to other businesses usually do better on LinkedIn.
Can I use AI tools to write my social media posts?
Yes, for first drafts and for ideas when you’re stuck. The posts still need your real photos and details from your own business, because AI text on its own reads the same as every other account using it.
How long does it take for social media to bring in customers?
Expect a few months of steady posting before you can judge it, and longer if the account is starting from nothing. Paid ads can bring results sooner, but they stop when the budget stops.
Will I lose control of my accounts if I hire a social media manager?
No, as long as the accounts are set up under your business and the social media manager is added as a user. Put ownership of the accounts and the content in the contract before any work starts.
If you want a second opinion on your own accounts, talk to FreshMove Media and we’ll tell you whether hiring makes sense yet.

