How to Choose a Digital Marketing Agency 7 Questions ftimg

How to Choose a Digital Marketing Agency: 7 Questions

Table of Contents

TL;DR:

To choose between digital marketing agencies for a small business, ask each one the same seven questions about who does the work, past results, the first 90 days, reporting, account ownership, contract terms, and total cost. Then compare the answers side by side. The agency that answers plainly and in writing is usually the safer hire.

Agency websites all promise more leads, and the sales calls sound alike. So the question most owners end up typing is how do I choose between digital marketing agencies for my small business. The quickest way we know is to ask every agency the same seven questions and compare what comes back.

Key takeaways

  • Asking every agency the same seven questions makes their answers easy to compare.
  • Your business should own its domain, website, ad accounts, and analytics from the first day.
  • A monthly report should show leads and what each lead cost, with clicks and impressions as supporting detail.
  • A short contract with a clear exit is a sign the agency expects to keep you by doing good work.

How do I choose between digital marketing agencies for my small business?

Ask each agency the same seven questions, get the answers in writing, and compare them side by side. A pitch is built to impress you. A written answer to a direct question tells you how the agency works once the contract is signed.

Here is the checklist we’d use if we were the ones hiring.

  1. Ask who will do the work on your account and who you will talk to each month.
  2. Ask for results from a business like yours, and for a client you can call.
  3. Ask what the agency will do in the first 90 days.
  4. Ask how results get reported and which numbers the report covers.
  5. Ask who owns the website and the ad accounts if you part ways.
  6. Ask how long the contract runs and how you get out of it.
  7. Ask what the total cost is and what the fee leaves out.

Send the list before the call if you can. An agency that has good answers will be glad to get it.

What should a digital marketing agency show me before I sign?

Before you sign, an agency should show you the people who will work on your account, a client you can call, a written plan for the first 90 days, and a sample report. Those four things cover the first half of the checklist, and none of them takes an honest agency more than a day to pull together.

The people matter more than owners expect. At many agencies the person who sells you is gone after the kickoff call, and the work goes to someone you’ve never met or to a contractor. Ask for names. Ask how many accounts each person handles.

For proof, a case study on a website is a start, but a phone number is better. Ten minutes with a current client tells you whether the agency returns calls and whether the results in the case study held up.

The 90-day plan doesn’t have to be long. It should say what gets fixed or built first and why, whether that’s search engine optimization or a new website. If the plan reads the same for a plumber as it would for a dentist, the agency hasn’t looked at your business yet.

How should an agency report results?

An agency should report every month on the leads it produced and what each lead cost, in a report you can read in about ten minutes. Calls, form fills, and booked appointments belong at the top. Clicks and impressions help explain those numbers, and they belong further down.

Ask for your own login to the tools behind the report. That means Google Analytics, your Google Business Profile, and the ad account if you’re running Google Ads. With your own access you can check any number yourself, and most owners never need to because knowing they can is enough.

Ask what happens in a bad month too. A good answer is specific about what the agency would look at and what it would change.

Who owns the website and ad accounts when I hire an agency?

Your business should own the domain, the website, the ad accounts, and the analytics, with the agency added as a user. This is the question owners skip most often, and it’s the one that causes the most trouble when a relationship ends.

Some agencies register everything under their own name. If you leave, you may lose the ad account history, or find out the website was rented and stays behind. Rebuilding from nothing costs months.

So ask it directly, and ask for the answer in the contract. If the agency is handling your website design, the contract should say the finished site and its content are yours once it’s paid for.

What should the contract and the price include?

The contract should state the length of the term, how to cancel, and exactly what work the monthly fee covers. Price only makes sense next to that list of work, which is why two proposals with the same fee can be very different deals.

On term, our opinion is that shorter is better for a first contract. SEO does need several months to show results, and an agency is right to tell you so. But needing time is different from locking you in for a year with no exit. Look for a cancellation clause with reasonable notice.

On cost, ask for the full number, and ask which digital marketing services it pays for. Ad spend is usually paid to Google or Meta on top of the agency’s fee, and some agencies charge separately for setup, hosting, or content. Have each agency fill in the same four lines (monthly fee, ad spend, one-time costs, and anything billed extra) so the totals can be compared.

Does it matter if the agency is in Richmond?

It matters most when your customers are local, because an agency in Richmond already knows the area you serve and can sit down with you in person. A business that sells across Virginia or ships nationally can put less weight on location and more on the seven answers.

For a business that depends on nearby customers, a lot of the work is local, which means your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and how you show up on the map. An agency that provides SEO services in Richmond every day has seen what the competition in Short Pump or Midlothian looks like for your trade. It’s also harder to ignore a client whose shop is fifteen minutes away.

FAQ

How long does it take to see results from a digital marketing agency?

Paid ads can bring leads within the first few weeks, and SEO usually takes several months. Ask each agency what you should expect to see at 30, 60, and 90 days so you have something to hold them to.

Should I hire an agency or a freelancer?

A freelancer works well when you need one thing done, like running an ad account. An agency makes more sense when you need a website, search, and ads working together, since one team is responsible for all of it.

What are the red flags when hiring a digital marketing agency?

The biggest red flag is a guaranteed number one ranking on Google, which no agency can promise. Others include vague answers about who does the work, and refusing to give you access to your own accounts.

How many agencies should I talk to before deciding?

Two or three is enough for most small businesses. Fewer leaves you with nothing to compare, and more than that mostly adds sales calls.

What should I have ready before the first call with an agency?

Have a rough monthly budget, the number of leads you get now, and what a new customer is worth to you. With those numbers the agency can tell you what’s realistic, and you can tell whether they listened.

Bring these seven questions to a call with us and we’ll answer each one in writing. Contact FreshMove Media to set one up.